In the world of modern combat aviation, few names command as much respect as the F-16 Fighting Falcon. Revered for its agility, speed, and versatility, the F-16 has been a cornerstone of air forces around the world for decades. But what if there was a contender—an aircraft that could hold its own against the Falcon, or even outmaneuver it in certain situations? It sounds almost impossible, given the F-16's storied legacy, but there exists a plane that could challenge its supremacy: the Su-35 Flanker-E.
Manufactured by Russia’s Sukhoi Design Bureau, the Su-35 is often considered a generation ahead of the F-16 in terms of raw performance, avionics, and maneuverability. Though the F-16 has been a formidable adversary, the Su-35 brings a whole new level of sophistication to aerial warfare.
Super Maneuverability: The F-16's Weakness
One of the key advantages the Su-35 holds over the F-16 is its supermaneuverability. While the F-16 is incredibly agile for a fourth-generation fighter, it still relies on traditional aerodynamic principles. The Su-35, however, is a fifth-generation fighter, equipped with thrust vectoring nozzles—allowing it to change the direction of its engine thrust. This gives it the ability to perform breathtaking maneuvers that would leave an F-16 in the dust.
The Pugachev’s Cobra maneuver, which the Su-35 can execute with ease, is a prime example of this. By dramatically increasing the angle of attack, the Su-35 can abruptly lose speed without losing control, putting it in a position to surprise opponents with high-speed reversals. The F-16, in contrast, while nimble, is limited by its conventional aerodynamic controls and struggles to match the Su-35’s agility in certain dogfights.
Advanced Avionics and Radar Systems
The Su-35 is not just about physical maneuvering—it also packs some of the most cutting-edge electronics in the world. The aircraft is equipped with the Irbis-E radar, a powerful multi-functional radar system that can track up to 30 targets simultaneously while engaging 8 of them at once. This gives the Su-35 an unparalleled advantage in terms of situational awareness. It’s able to detect threats at greater ranges than the F-16’s radar, giving it more time to make tactical decisions and strike first.
The F-16’s radar, although sophisticated, can be overwhelmed by modern threats and simply doesn’t offer the same level of tracking capability as the Su-35. With advanced radar jamming and countermeasures built into the Su-35, it becomes a much more formidable opponent when it comes to electronic warfare.
The Armament Advantage
The Su-35 isn’t just about agility and electronics; its armament options are a significant factor in its superiority over the F-16. While both aircraft are highly capable of carrying a wide range of missiles and bombs, the Su-35 has a distinct edge in the air-to-air missile department. Equipped with RVV-SD and R-77 medium-range missiles, the Su-35 has longer-range targeting and firing capabilities, making it a dangerous adversary for the F-16, which uses the AIM-120 AMRAAM.
Additionally, the Su-35 can carry a larger payload of weapons, including the deadly Kh-31 anti-radiation missiles and Kh-59 air-to-ground missiles, giving it flexibility to engage a wider variety of targets. This versatility makes the Su-35 not just a fighter, but a true multi-role aircraft.
Stealth and Survivability
While the F-16 may not be a stealth fighter in the traditional sense, it’s equipped with modern technologies designed to reduce radar cross-section. However, the Su-35, although not a true stealth fighter either, has been designed with some degree of low-observable features and advanced radar-absorbing materials, which help reduce its detectability in certain circumstances.
Furthermore, the Su-35’s sheer size and engine power give it superior survivability when it comes to evasive action. The Su-35 is capable of operating at higher speeds and altitudes than the F-16, allowing it to escape hostile engagements or reposition rapidly for a counterattack. With its twice-redundant fly-by-wire system and superior engine thrust, the Su-35 is a tough adversary that can recover from a fight when things get tight.
The Verdict: Does the Su-35 Really Beat the F-16?
In many respects, the Su-35 represents a quantum leap in terms of maneuverability, avionics, and armament, placing it in an advantageous position against the F-16. However, it’s essential to recognize that the F-16’s strengths lie in its versatility, combat record, and global adoption. It’s an aircraft that has been battle-tested across multiple theaters of war and remains a highly reliable and effective weapon in many air forces.
That said, if the two planes were to square off in a dogfight, the Su-35’s supermaneuverability, superior radar, and more advanced missile systems would likely give it the edge. In air-to-air combat, the Su-35 would have the upper hand in most scenarios, especially in terms of agility and situational awareness. However, the F-16’s lighter frame, versatility in multi-role operations, and outstanding track record can’t be overlooked.
In the end, the Su-35 is a formidable adversary, and while it might not always guarantee victory, it is certainly one of the few aircraft capable of challenging the F-16 in a one-on-one dogfight.