Meghan Markle’s birthday should have been a low-key moment—an elegant post, a sweet message, perhaps a photo with her children or husband Prince Harry. Instead, it turned into yet another social media storm. With just one birthday message—shared by her own lifestyle brand’s account—Meghan found herself the center of harsh ridicule, with critics dubbing her the “Duchess of Dodgy” over what many saw as an embarrassingly self-congratulatory move.
.jpg)
The message, which appeared on the new Instagram page of her brand American Riviera Orchard, was a glittering, slow-motion video of Meghan twirling in a strapless dress in soft California sunlight. The caption? A vague, almost cryptic birthday wish that some believed was written by Meghan herself… to Meghan.
To many viewers, it read like an awkward self-love letter wrapped in overly polished PR gloss. There were no visible wishes from close friends, no reposts of family greetings, no Harry in sight—just Meghan, Meghan, Meghan. In a world where authenticity is everything and curated content is constantly under the microscope, this came off to critics as tone-deaf at best, and deeply narcissistic at worst.
Social media didn’t hold back. “She’s now writing birthday cards to herself?” one user posted. “That’s not empowerment, it’s just embarrassing.” Others chimed in with memes and jabs, with the nickname “Duchess of Dodgy” trending briefly on X (formerly Twitter). Some users joked that even the royal family must have cringed, especially after years of strained relations and carefully controlled public messaging.
The timing didn’t help either. Meghan’s brand, still shrouded in mystery months after its launch, has yet to deliver any actual products. No official website, no release dates—just pastel photos, wine glasses, and stylized clips of fruit baskets and fountain pens. Followers of the brand’s account have been left confused and underwhelmed, and this birthday stunt only deepened the frustration.
One PR expert noted that Meghan’s mistake wasn’t celebrating herself—it was how she did it. “This could have been a perfect moment to humanize her, to show her as a mother, a friend, a woman reflecting on her journey,” they said. “Instead, it felt like a trailer for a perfume ad. It lacked warmth. It lacked connection.”
The backlash echoes a larger problem Meghan and Harry have faced repeatedly since stepping back from royal duties in 2020: tone misfires. Whether it’s the high-production Oprah interview, the slick Netflix series, or the infamous Spotify podcast deal that ended prematurely, their messaging often feels too polished, too scripted, and ultimately, out of touch with the average person.
And while Meghan certainly has her loyal supporters—many of whom defended the birthday post as graceful and self-affirming—the critics were louder this time. It’s a reminder that in today’s culture, public perception is won not through perfect branding, but through genuine moments of vulnerability. Something that seemed sorely missing from this birthday post.
Whether this was just a misstep or a sign of deeper issues within Meghan’s inner circle remains to be seen. But one thing is certain: if the goal was to make a graceful statement and reintroduce herself on her birthday, it backfired. Instead of a celebration, she got a takedown.
For someone who once seemed poised to redefine modern royalty, the journey has taken a strange turn—and the internet, as always, is watching with popcorn in hand.